Angiulo: When Working From Home Causes a Lawsuit
Monday, October 12, 2015
In Cossart v. United Excel Corporation a Kansas Corporation found themselves in exactly this spot when a dispute arouse with an employee. The argument revolved around money. More specifically, a salesperson believed he was owed $219,000.00 in commission and the employer set the figure at $62,000.00 which is how the fight started.
The employee filed suit and the employer, after some litigation, filed a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction. When this motion was filed, the question became whether, or not, the Federal Court of Massachusetts has authority over a defendant from Kansas for the purpose of the lawsuit. In order to answer that question, the First Circuit looked to both the due process clause of the Federal Constitution and Massachusetts law for legal authority.
While the technical legal issues could fill up pages, the factual points supporting why the lawsuit could move forward in Massachusetts are simple. The employer negotiated an employment contract with a employee who would be working from home in Massachusetts. The employer provided material support including video conference equipment, a computer, printer, and cell phone. The employer also provided a telephone number for the employee that re-routed telephone calls from Kansas to Massachusetts. In addition, the employer company registered a general sales office here in Massachusetts the day after the employment contract was signed. The employee used this equipment in his home to solicit sales and was, at all times relevant to the dispute, residing and working from Massachusetts.
The court used these facts, as well as others, to find three major points supporting why the defendant corporation was subject to the jurisdiction of courts in Massachusetts. First, both the employer and employee knew that performance on the employement contract would occur here in the Commonwealth. In addition, by choosing a Massachusetts resident who worked from that state, the employer was choosing to receive the benefits and detriments of Massachusetts law. Finally, the defendant did not show any exceptional burden of the case being heard in Massachusetts.
The business world can be a tough place. While employers may see this decision as frustrating, it is also a way to forecast risk. As it stands in the First Circuit, if you reach out to find talent you may face a lawsuit far from home. Considering this potential outcome during the formation of an employment contract may prevent bigger problems in the future.
- Angiulo: Elder Abuse, Powers of Attorney and Harassment Prevention Orders
- Angiulo: Drug Convictions, Firearms and the Supreme Court
- Angiulo: SJC Says Breath Tests in Massachusetts Are in Question
- Angiulo: Supreme Court Decides When Online Threats Become Criminal Acts
- Angiulo: SJC Defines the Limits of Parental Discipline
- Angiulo: Unringing the Bell of Falsified Drug Tests
- Angiulo: When is a Business Owner Responsible For a Customer’s Injury?
- Angiulo: SJC Affirms Juvenile Suspects’ Rights During Interrogation
- Angiulo: Drug Dogs, Traffic Stops and the U.S. Supreme Court
- Angiulo: SJC Says Marijuana Cultivation Alone is Not Proof of Crime
- Angiulo: SJC Makes Adoption Easier For Same Sex Parents
- Angiulo: The Supreme Court, the Death Penalty, and the Constitution
- Angiulo: Land of the Free, Home of Live Nude Dancing
- Angiulo: Employee Injuries and Employer Liability
- Angiulo: Sometimes a Spouse Really Does Get Half Your Stuff in a Divorce
- Angiulo: Federal 1st Circuit Court of Appeals Says Growing Weed Still a Crime
- Angiulo: Promises Made in Auto Insurance Applications May Stick
- Angiulo: Massachusetts Motor Vehicle Stops and the Odor of Marijuana Continued
- Angiulo: Overtime Pay for Employees and Employer Obligations
- Angiulo: Challenging the Legality of Motor Vehicle Stops by Police
- Angiulo: SJC Looks at Mortgage Foreclosure Process in Massachusetts
- Angiulo: An Insurance Agent at the Intersection of Business Model and Criminal Act
- Angiulo: Drunk Driving Charges and Commercial Driver’s License Suspensions
- Angiulo: Freedom of Speech and Political Campaigns
- Angiulo: Cell Phone Tracking in Massachusetts