Weiss: House Fails to Pass GOP’s Balanced Budget Amendment
Monday, April 16, 2018
House Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte (R-Va.), introduced H.J. Res. 2, which he notes is nearly identical to text in legislation that passed the House in 1995, but failed in the Senate by one vote. This would be the Virginia Congressman’s last chance to push for passage of a BBA because he is not seeking re-election at the end of this term.
Last October. House Speake Paul Ryan (R-WI) agreed to vote on Goodlatte’s BBA, in exchange for conservative votes from the Republican Study Committee, chaired by Mark Walker (R-NC), on a procedural budget measure needed for Republicans to move forward on tax reform.
BBA Gets Thumbs Down by House Lawmakers
As expect, the House GOP’s BBA was defeated by a vote of 233 to 184, falling far short (over 50 lawmakers) of the two-thirds vote required for passage of an amendment under the Constitution. Six Republicans voted against it while only seven Democrats voted for it. But, the GOP’s BBA had little chance of becoming law because the required support of two-thirds in the Senate and Democratic Senators unified in their opposition, and finally the requirement that 38 states ratify the constitutional amendment.
“Our extraordinary fiscal crisis demands an extraordinary solution. We must rise above partisanship and join together to send a balanced budget amendment to the states for ratification.
I urge all my colleagues to join me in supporting this amendment and in freeing our children and grandchildren from the burden of a crippling debt they had no hand in creating, so they can be free to chart their own futures for themselves and for their own posterity,” Goodlatte said during the House floor on Thursday evening.
During the four-hour debate, House Republican Conference Chair Cathy McMorris Rodgers (R-WA), asked Congress to balance its budget like typical families do. She said, “Families across the country sit down at their kitchen tables every month and make tough decisions to balance their budget so that they can make ends meet. Just like American families, the federal government should spend within its means. A Balanced Budget Amendment, which requires a two-third majority in both chambers of Congress to pass, is a needed and important mechanism to restore fiscal discipline. “
On the House Floor, Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi called the BBA “a brazen assault on seniors, children and working families – the American people we were elected to protect.”
“Make no mistake, this GOP con job has nothing to do with fiscal responsibility. It is not balanced in terms of money because of their GOP Tax Scam that’s placed us in a bad spot fiscally and it’s not balanced in terms of values,” says Pelosi, noting that GOP fiscal responsibility comes down to “ransacking Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security and breaking our nation’s sacred promise of dignity and security for seniors and families.”
Before the House vote on the BBA, Darrell M. West, vice president and director of Governance Studies at the Washington, D.C.-based the Brookings Institution, stated “I would be surprised if the bill made it through Congress.” He added, “It’s hypocritical for Republicans to support a balanced budget amendment after they cut taxes by $1.5 trillion and added significantly to the federal deficit. Voters will see through that and understand the vote is about scoring political points and not making good public policy.”
House Lawmakers Bombarded with Opposition Letters
Days before the House vote the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare (NCPSSM), AARP expressed opposition to the passage of the BBA by sending a letter to the Hill, urging House lawmakers to reject the GOP’s constitutional amendment. Hundreds of aging, healthcare, educational, union, and business groups were cited in the April 12, 2018 issue of The Congressional Record as opposing the amendment.
Max Richtman, NCPSSM’s President and CEO, wrote House lawmakers warning that a BBA would unravel the nation’s social safety net by making gigantic entitlement cuts by blocking benefit payments from the Social Security and Medicare Part A trust funds because “all federal expenditures, including these earned benefits, would have to be covered by revenue collected in the same year. “
A BBA would also force Congress to make huge spending cuts to Medicare Parts B, C and D, Medicaid, and many other social safety net programs for seniors, to rein in the nation’s deficit and pushing lawmakers to make “massive new tax cuts.,” says Richtman.
“While the balanced budget amendment did not dictate any particular approach to deficit reduction, by altering established Congressional voting procedures it would have increased the likelihood that the fiscal policies adopted in coming decades would favor the well-off at the expense of middle- and low-income Americans. The amendment would have required a two-thirds vote of the full membership of the House and Senate to raise taxes. Spending cuts, by contrast, would continue to require only a majority of those present and voting and could be passed on a voice vote,” observed Richtman.
Finally, Richtman noted that the risk of a federal government default would increase because a BBA requires a three-fifths vote of both the House and the Senate to raise the national debt limit, rather than the current simple majority.
AARP Executive Vice President Nancy LeaMond also expressed opposition to the BBA in a letter to House lawmakers charging that the amendment would impact the solvency of Social Security and Medicare, “subjecting both programs to potentially deep cuts without regard to the impact on the health and financial security of individuals.” Programs that provide meals or heating assistance to low income seniors would also see available resources diminish, she predicted, she said.
The lack of a dependable Social Security and Medicare benefit [if a BBA was passed] would be devastating for millions of Americans. Social Security is currently the principal source of income for half of older American households receiving benefits, and roughly one in five households depend on Social Security benefits for nearly all (90 percent or more) of their income. Over 50 million Americans depend on Medicare, half of whom have incomes of less than $24,150. Even small fluctuations in premiums and cost sharing would have a significant impact on the personal finances of older and disabled Americans,” said LeaMond.
Midterm Elections Just Six Months Away
The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) predicted early this week that the annual government’s deficit is projected to be $ 1 trillion next year. And the nation’s $21 trillion debt would skyrocket to 33 trillion by 20028. With the midterm elections just six months away, combined with the CBO’s recently released economic analysis, the Republican party’s image as being the fiscally responsible political party is now shattered.
Even controlling both chambers of Congress and with President Donald Trump in the White House, GOP lawmakers must now look for political issues that may resonate with their constituents. Further attempts to dismantle Socials Security and Medicare may not be the way to go.
Herb Weiss, LRI’12, is a Pawtucket writer covering aging, healthcare and medical issues. To purchase Taking Charge: Collected Stories on Aging Boldly, a collection of 79 of his weekly commentaries, go to herbweiss.com.
- Herb Weiss: Presidential Candidates Mum on Social Security
- Herb Weiss: Revelations that Bring Together Heaven and Earth
- Herb Weiss: How the Presidential Election Impacts Social Security
- Herb Weiss: GOP Trial Balloon Called “Trojan Horse”
- Weiss: Assistance to Employee Caregivers Good for Everyone’s Bottom Line
- Weiss: Trump Budget Could Fray Nation’s Social Security Net, Hurt Seniors
- Weiss: Senate Health Bill Vote Expected This Week, Dems Call Bill “Meaner” Than House Version
- Weiss: GOP Senators Avoid Angry Constituents During July Recess
- Weiss: Social Security, Medicare Are Solvent..For Now
- Weiss: CBO Numbers Says GOP Health Plan Benefits Young, Healthy…Not Seniors
- Weiss: GOP Health Care Reform Moves to Senate
- Weiss: GOP Health Care Proposal Pull at Last Moment
- Weiss: Experts Say Isolation and Loneliness Impacting More Older Americans
- Weiss: House Budget Committee Plan Calls for Privatization of Medicare
- Weiss: Three GOP Senators Derail ‘Skinny’ Maneuvers
- Weiss: Pets Can Bring You Health, Happiness
- Weiss: Congress Passes RAISE Family Care Givers Act
- Weiss: Older Americans to Benefit from Bipartisan Budget Act
- Weiss: Trump Budget Proposal Makes Draconian Cuts to Aging Programs
- Weiss: Trump’s Budget Proposal Comes ‘Dead on Arrival’ to Aging Groups
- Weiss: New Report Says Alzheimer’s Disease Is Now Major Public Health Issue
- Weiss: Medicare Takes a Blow Under GOP’s Major Tax Plan Fix
- Weiss: Aging Groups - House GOP Tax Rewrite a Turkey
- Weiss: Report - Cognitive-Simulating Activities Good for Your Brain’s Health
- Weiss: On Taking a Stand Against Racism & Antisemitism
- Weiss: Analysis Says That Aging Veterans at Greater Risk of Alzheimer’s Disease
- Weiss: Senate Aging Panel Calls for Improved Emergency Preparation & Response
- Weiss: With Tax Day Looming, Watch Out for IRS Imposters