Welcome! Login | Register
 

Finneran: The Day the World Disappeared—Finneran: The Day the World Disappeared

Fairman Cowan Municipal Leadership Award Presented to Morgans—Fairman Cowan Municipal Leadership Award Presented to Philip…

ERA Key Realty Services Adds Hamel as Realtor—ERA Key Realty Services Adds Hamel as Realtor

Much Better to Buy a Home Than Rent in Worcester, Says Study—Worcester is 2nd Best City to Buy a…

Chef Walter’s Flavors + Knowledge: Meat & Cheese Calzone—Chef Walter’s Flavors + Knowledge: Meat & Cheese…

1/3 of MA Workers Call for Paid Leave Following Loss of Pet—1/3 of MA Workers Call for Paid Leave…

New England Colleges See Double-Digit Rise in Tuition & Fees—New England Colleges See Double-Digit Rise in Tuition…

Man Arrested with Possession of Illegal Gun in Worcester—Man Arrested with Possession of Illegal Gun in…

Horowitz: Trump Administration Takes Its Climate Change Denial International—Horowitz: Trump Administration Takes Its Climate Change Denial…

Worcester Police Offer Series of Holiday Safety Tips—Worcester Police Offer Series of Holiday Safety Tips

 
 

College Admissions: SAT Plagued With Issues

Monday, June 15, 2015

 

Students prepare for weeks, months, and some for years. Parents can spend hundreds or even thousands of dollars on tutors and prep courses. Then, SAT test day arrives. There is an assumption that the test administration will run smoothly; that assumption is flawed. The reality is that the Collegeboard and its’ test centers have been plagued for years with issues and errors, none more glaring than on June 6. 

Nationwide, proctors told nearly half a million students that they had 20 minutes to complete a reading section. The printed test that the students received said that they had 25 minutes. Shortly after the test finished at noon Eastern Time, the error was identified, but it was too late. Test takers waited anxiously to receive word as to whether their tests would be graded or invalidated. Ultimately, the Collegeboard did decide to grade the tests, stating in a press release, "We have deliberately constructed both the reading and the math tests to include three equal sections with roughly the same level of difficulty. If one of the three sections is jeopardized, the correlation among sections is sufficient to be able to deliver reliable scores." Unfortunately, students who felt they did particularly well on the discarded section are left wondering if their scores will be disadvantaged. 

This was not the first time that a lack of quality control has colored the reputation of the Collegeboard. In 2006, a Pearson Educational Measurement audit revealed that 4,000 students received artificially low scores due to high moisture levels when tests were scanned for grading. Allegations have circulated for years regarding massive cheating on the SAT in Asian countries, and last month, 15 Chinese nationals were charged for impersonating students at testing centers. In 2011, seven Long Island test takers were arrested in an SAT cheating probe. Locally, my students have reported a variety of unsatisfactory situations over the last 5 years. Some have been at test centers with insufficient desks, forcing several students take the test on a window sill. Others have been distracted by blaring music coming from the iPod headphones of an instructor as they took the test. And a few with extended time for learning differences have experienced problems with instructions and timing.

All of these inconsistencies and errors reignite the national debate as to whether standardized testing is an accurate measure of student knowledge. A 3 year study by the National Association for College Admissions Counseling, titled “Defining Promise: Optional Standardized Testing Policies in American College and University Admissions” concluded in 2014 that college GPAs for students submitting SATs and not submitting SATs at test optional colleges did not differ substantially:

“With almost 123,000 students at 33 widely differing institutions, the differences between submitters and non-submitters are five one-hundredths of a GPA point, and six-tenths of one percent in graduation rates. By any standard, these are trivial differences.”

Reacting to the June 6 SAT debacle, Bob Schaeffer, Public Education Director for FairTest said “This foul-up will further accelerate the movement for college and university admissions offices to drop SAT requirements."

Cristiana Quinn, M.Ed. is the founder of College Admission Advisors, LLC which provides strategic college counseling, SAT prep and athletic recruiting services www.collegeadvisorsonline.com.

 

Related Slideshow: Top New England ROI Colleges in 2014 Ranked By Forbes

Prev Next

2. Dartmouth College

Hanover, NH

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 100

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $27,464

Percentage of Students that Donate: 44%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

3. Williams College

Williamstown, MA

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 99.9

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $23,346

Percentage of Students that Donate: 53%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

5. Bowdoin College

Brunswick, ME

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 99.4

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $19,598

Percentage of Students that Donate: 44%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

6. Amherst College

Amherst, MA

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 99

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $18,752

Percentage of Students that Donate: 52%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

8. Wellesley College

Wellesley, MA

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 98.5

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $17,958

Percentage of Students that Donate: 47%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

9. Brown University

Providence, RI

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 97.4

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $21,694

Percentage of Students that Donate: 29%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

12. Yale University

New Haven, CT

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 96.7

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $30,033

Percentage of Students that Donate: 28%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

13. MIT

Cambridge, MA

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 95.1

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $36,763

Percentage of Students that Donate: 25%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

20. Harvard University

Cambridge, MA

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 91.4

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $25,122

Percentage of Students that Donate: 19%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

22. Middlebury College

Middlebury, VT

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 90.6

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $14,033

Percentage of Students that Donate: 42%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

33. Trinity College

Hartford, CT

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 84

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $12,772

Percentage of Students that Donate: 42%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

34. Brandeis University

Waltham, MA

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 83.8

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $14,045

Percentage of Students that Donate: 22%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

35. Colby College

Waterville, ME

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 79.2

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $12,092

Percentage of Students that Donate: 39%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

41. Smith College

Northampton, MA

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 73.8

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $11,555

Percentage of Students that Donate: 32%

Forbes Ranking Page

Prev Next

49. Wesleyan University

Middleton, CT

Grateful Graduate Index Score: 53.6

Median Donation Per Student Over a 10 Year Period: $9,358

Percentage of Students that Donate: 41%

Forbes Ranking Page

 
 

Related Articles

 

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.

 
Delivered Free Every
Day to Your Inbox