Angiulo: CBS Benghazi Report Highlights Power of First Amendment
Monday, November 11, 2013
Lack of press freedom in the Arab world
Take Bassem Youssef of Egypt as an example. This is the guy commonly referred to as the “Jon Stewart” of Egypt because of his satire and willingness to use powerful people in his punch lines. At the beginning of November the Egyptian Television Network CBC indefinitely suspended his program. According to the Arabic Network for Human Rights Information (ANHRI), this suspension was due to pressure from a faction of the Egyptian Government, as well as from the network itself. This suspension effectively silenced a voice because of its message. Other recent releases from ANHRI document similar tactics in Arabic nations to limit the free exchange of ideas. These include, but aren't limited to, a ten-year prison sentence for a blogger critical of certain royal families and the arrest, secret detention and refusal to identify charges against another journalist arrested on November 7, 2013.
But this isn't just a problem in Arabic nations. The 2013 World Press Freedom Index produced by Reporters Without Borders documents the best, and worst, of how regional and national authorities treat journalists. Reporters Without Borders claim there is trouble all over: from China's censorship of internet content, to the use of violence in Belarus to silence dissidents and the limitation of television airwaves in Paraguay.
Press freedom in the United States
Does the United States have its own issues? Of course. Am I willing to cite the http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/charters/bill_of_rights_transcript.html" target="_blank">First Amendment's Freedom of the Press as a unique, maybe exceptional, advantage we hold against tyranny? Absolutely.
Let's take the CBS Benghazi report as an example. Exactly what happened that night, how something so terrible could have happened, and that different versions of events were coming out of the White House has been a topic the Obama Administration would rather not have to deal with. If we were in another country, even considering an investigative report on this subject could result in arrest and detention or even execution. As it stands, it is now up to the individual citizens to decide whether the person interviewed by CBS was recalling an accurate version of events or not. Thanks to our free press, we have learned that this same individual going by the name Morgan Jones apparently provided reports shortly after the event to his employer and the FBI that are fundamentally different from what he wrote in his book and told to CBS. Not only that but, apparently, his real name is Dylan Davies.
So, we as citizens and consumers of media are left with conflicting evidence and a choice of what to believe. We could believe that the account Mr. Davies provided to CBS should not be relied upon because he has given different versions and is therefore unreliable. We could, in the alternative, choose to believe Mr. Davies' assertion that the incident report from his employer was not written by him and that he told the FBI the same thing he told CBS. Sure, that gets a bit heavy on the conspiracy theory side of things, but I submit that with the information available at this time the issue is squarely framed as a “believe this or believe that” question.
And the beautiful part of all of this is because we have more available information to consider it's our choice which version of events to believe. That is what the guarantee of a free press means: the freedom to make your own decisions and form opinions about events based on sometimes conflicting information. The alternative is listening to only what an authority wants you to know.
Related Articles
- Leonardo Angiulo: A New Law That Will Let You Have More E-Privacy
- Leonardo Angiulo: MA Supreme Court Brings Wiretapping To Your Cellphone
- Leonardo Angiulo: The Steroid Defense For Murder?
- Leonardo Angiulo: Aaron Hernandez Should Probably Lawyer Up
- Leonardo Angiulo: Mass. Takes 17 Year Olds Off The Criminal Hook
- Leonardo Angiulo: Two Supreme Court Rulings That Seem Like Sci-Fi
- Leonardo Angiulo: Auto Accidents + Recovering Damages
- Leonardo Angiulo: Massachusetts Family Sees Justice After 40 Years
- Leonardo Angiulo: Using Contract Law To Spur Congressional Action
- Leonardo Angiulo: Can A Minor Be Arrested For Cyberbullying?
- Leonardo Angiulo: Putting A Price On Wrongful Death
- Leonardo Angiulo: What Happens To Digital Property When You Die?
- Leonardo Angiulo: Criminal Justice—What The TV Shows Leave Out
- Leonardo Angiulo: Something To Be Proud Of On Independence Day
- Leonardo Angiulo: What You May Not Know About The DOMA Decision
- Leonardo Angiulo: How Much Privacy Did You Lose This Week? A Lot.
- Leonardo Angiulo: Surviving Party Season With Your Teenager
- Leonardo Angiulo: What’s Next For America’s Voting Rights Act
- Leonardo Angiulo: Keeping The Powerful From Abusing Our Money
- Leonardo Angiulo: Swearing To Tell The Truth Means Something
- Leonardo Angiulo: Who Wins in the NFL Concussion Settlement?
- Leonardo Angiulo: ‘Self-Defense’ and Massachusetts Law
- Leonardo Angiulo: Legal Lessons From The Salem State Stabbings
- Leonardo Angiulo: The Royal Baby + Your Estate Planning
- Leonardo Angiulo: Why We Don’t Have The Death Penalty In Mass.
Follow us on Pinterest Google + Facebook Twitter See It Read It