Julia Steiny: If Only Congress Could Get A Divorce
Wednesday, October 02, 2013
-- Donald Shriver, President Emeritus, Union Theological Seminary
Statistically, children have the best health-and-welfare results when raised by their married, biological parents -- with one huge caveat. Kids growing up in high-conflict households tend to have stats that look like those in single-parent families, stressed by tight resources.
All kids have stress and adversity. But warring parents cause what's called "toxic stress" in their kids, according to the CDC. Often, over time, such stress makes kids physically sick. When steeped in their parents' yelling, broken dishes and ugly silences, kids suffer much higher rates of asthma, suicide, heart, liver and lung disease than their peers in peaceful homes. Domestic fighting wrecks kids' social, emotional, and mental health with decreased graduation and college-going, increased drug and alcohol use, and early sex and teen parenting.
As Dr. Philip M. Stahl put it, "In many ways, it appears that the life of the child must stop while the arguments between the parents continue." Kids aren't doing their homework when Mom and Dad are duking it out in the kitchen. Normal development stops as kids pray that harmony resume and that the family please, please stay together. If the adult relationship stabilizes, the effects of the earlier toxic stress can actually be reversed. Kids thrive in stability, with regular family dinners where everyone talks things through, building faith that together the family can face adversity.
Life itself is rife with conflict.
All families fight. People disagree. But in healthy relationships, no matter how spitting mad the partners are at times, they develop ways of negotiating solutions.
Donald Shriver -- quoted above -- is an international hot-spot expert, participating in incendiary negotiations like the South African Peace Commission. A man dedicated to easing rage, vengeance and hate, Shriver wrote a book called An Ethic For Enemies. I'll boil his thesis down to two rules:
One: Stay at the table. Don't be running off for your baseball bat, Glock 9 or lawyer. A good resolution, suitable to all parties, is impossible unless everyone sticks it out with one another. Take cool-off breaks, but no matter what: stay at the table.
Two: Be able to state the other guy's position without snarky editorial. You don't have to agree, sympathize or concede a thing; just wrap your head around what the other guy wants or needs, well enough that your "enemy" feels heard and understood. Like all Restorative paths, this doesn't always work. That's okay, because the alternative, war and head-butting, never work. Restorative practices work most of the time, and the results -- as in South Africa -- are often marvels of the human spirit and mind.
Conflict is a marvelous if dangerous thing. Creative, even hot-headed tension can lead to decisions that make things better for everyone. Or to people trying to destroy one another, taking down those around them as collateral damage. In families, the unintended casualties are the kids. In the case of the government, well, that would be the rest of us.
If you want harmony, model the behavior you want to see.
Family counselors routinely tell parents they'll need to be good role models, or they'll get back what they dish out. Yell, hit or withhold love and the kids will do that too. If such advice is good for families, why not Congress? How dare Congress scrap with one another like junk-yard dogs, for all the public to see? If a teacher yells at a kid in a hallway, she just gave the entire student body license to yell. Monkey see; monkey do. When Congress commits verbal violence, they give the nation license to do the same. Leaders should be modeling negotiation, listening, speaking from the heart. Parents need leaders to be their role models.
I need to understand and be able to express how my enemy imagines the ideal solution. So if ObamaCare ain't it, what is? Be specific. Granted, I live next door to the highly-successful, ever-improving home of RomneyCare, so I acknowledge bias. Still, Congress, what does it look like when we have it right? For America, all of America and not just some chosen few? Really hard question, complicated and nuanced. So put on those Congressional thinking caps and get to the table. No going for baseball bats or media uzis.
I'm no expert on the federal government, but after parenting myself and working in many schools, I understand modeling. Congress is an image of bad parenting on steroids. Structurally, they can't get a divorce. They can rip the country apart, but they can't rent a separate apartment, get a mediator and start custody arrangements. They have no choice but to get their eye on something bigger than themselves, their own importance, their next election and in short, their narcissism. How does the other guy see it and how, pray, are you going to make a country, a household, that at least listens respectfully to all sides?
Model the behavior you want to see. If this slugfest is really about healthcare, the resulting toxic stress is making us all sick.
Julia Steiny is a freelance columnist whose work also regularly appears at EducationNews.org. She is the founding director of the Youth Restoration Project, a restorative-practices initiative, currently building demonstration projects in Rhode Island. She consults for schools and government initiatives, including regular work for The Providence Plan for whom she analyzes data. For more detail, see juliasteiny.com or contact her at [email protected]or c/o GoLocalProv, 44 Weybosset Street, Providence, RI 02903.
- Julia Steiny: Best Beach Read—Paul Tough’s ‘How Children Succeed’
- Julia Steiny: High-Stakes Testing Works If Kids Go To School
- Julia Steiny: There Is No Health Without Mental Health
- Julia Steiny: Blackstone Valley Boasts a ‘Kick Butt’ School
- Julia Steiny: It’s Building Kids’ Vocabulary, Stupid
- Julia Steiny: UK’s Marc Armitage Brings Playwork To US Educators
- Julia Steiny: Bloodlust For Boston Bombers Won’t Aid Healing
- Julia Steiny: Middle-school Puberty–The Elephant in the Classroom
- Julia Steiny: What Mom Rats Can Teach Us About Child Rearing
- Julia Steiny: Bring Back The ‘C’ Grade
- Julia Steiny: Public Admits Being ‘Clueless’ About Education
- Julia Steiny: What The Numbers Tell Us About The Class of 2013
- Julia Steiny: Schools Help Minorities Become the Serfs of the Information Age.
- Julia Steiny: Bringing Kids In Trouble Back From The Brink
- Julia Steiny: Public Schools Owe Neglected Kids More Than Academics
- Julia Steiny: Why ‘Bad’ Moms Still Should Parent Their Kids
- Julia Steiny: A “Forest Kindergarten” Grows Great Kids
- Julia Steiny: Can’t Achieve STEM Goals Without Computer Science
- Julia Steiny: Recess Is Good For Mental Health
- Julia Steiny: A Smart Way To Engage Math-Haters
- Julia Steiny: Careful What You Want & How You Measure Getting It
- Julia Steiny: Recruiting Family Before Foster Care
- Julia Steiny: At Last! A Computer Science Course For Kids
- Julia Steiny: Great Communities Are Happy, Healing Places
- Julia Steiny: The Importance of Having a Father