Julia Steiny: Teach Real Algebra Instead of Wasting Time with Apps
Wednesday, November 06, 2013
So later on, Schanzer would create Bootstrap's curriculum. Because -- buyer beware! -- most of the apps and programs that currently promise to teach kids algebra are fun, but a total waste of time.
"When you hear, 'This is so amazing! These apps teach kids to program!' That's snake oil. Every minute your students spend on empty engagement while they're failing algebra, you're assuring that they're not going to college. Studies show that the grade kids get in Algebra I is the most significant grade to predict future income."
A man with a math mission
In college Schanzer searched for a way to improve math instruction through real programming, and found Program by Design (PxB, about which I've been writing for the last 2 weeks). While excellent, it's pitched too high, assuming strong math skills that challenged urban students haven't yet acquired. He vowed to redesign it one day -- after cashing in on his computer-science degree.
But his years working in the tech sector were no match for his passion. Plan "B," then. With an education degree in hand, he started teaching his beloved algebra in urban schools. But the programming tools available to his students were maddeningly off the mark. "First, none of the popular K-12 computer languages/teaching tools had anything to do with math, which seemed insane to me. They had things called "functions" and "variables," but they didn't behave at all like the functions and variables students see in their math classes. How's that supposed to help them? Students were expected to entertain themselves by playing with the tools, but it wasn't clear what they were supposed to learn."
"The student-engagement bandwagon has gone too far"
"The goal is to help kids get the computer to do something, because there is an intangible value in being in control. It's engaging, no question. So in the last 5 years, all the sexy languages are drag-and-drop programs, like Scratch and Alice. I have enormous respect for these tools, as long as they're a first step towards Python, Java. But by themselves, they are a terrific answer to just one question: How do we make it seem easy to code?"
Those programs have built-in blocks of code, represented by icons that kids can manipulate. But kids don't interact with the code itself, never mind write it or program.
"Typing code is hard. If you forget a semicolon, the program doesn't work. So the supposition has been that if they play with a tool, it will help them later. But that's not programming and it's not algebra. Classroom time is valuable. If you're spending 50 hours in the course of a year "coding" in block language, you're stealing time from real learning. Students get an "A" in high school and then go to college and find programming is something else entirely, and get totally turned off."
Bootstrap is born
Like a good Millenial, Schanzer founded a start-up to solve the problem. Bootstrap's programming language behaves like the algebra students learn in class, reinforcing honest-to-God algebraic concepts. Yes, Bootstrap teaches kids the basics of game building, but only by teaching the math that supports the code.
The materials are free and online, though professional development is available. Every lesson is cross-walked with the Common Core, assuring teachers that their efforts will result in real learning. A growing library provides homework assignments and warm-up activities. Teachers can use each lesson's script until they're familiar with the program. And a pre and post-test measures the learning.
"Teachers know if it's not real math. You have to do things the way teachers do it in a classroom. Bootstrap enforces mathematical behavior -- same vocabulary, steps, style as a math book. This is a math class." The fun video on Bootstrap's homepage shows kids loving the approach.
As luck would have it, Schanzer found himself Boston's subway one morning and noticed a guy, a German, working with Program by Design. Lo!, the man was none other than Matthias Felliesen, creator of PxD. With that chance meeting, Schnazer secured allies in his efforts to get math to urban kids. Bootstrap started to take off.
And if a Bootstrap student starts to soar, a teacher can point the budding computer-scientist to PxD for more challenge, and a pipeline to college.
Schanzer is fulfilling his college-born dream to propel bunches of kids into bright futures at places like Cornell. Absolutely, engagement is important. But the key all along has been to shore up math itself.
- Julia Steiny: A “Forest Kindergarten” Grows Great Kids
- Julia Steiny: Computer Science is Critical Thinking on Steroids
- Julia Steiny: Public Schools Owe Neglected Kids More Than Academics
- Julia Steiny: Why ‘Bad’ Moms Still Should Parent Their Kids
- Julia Steiny: A Smart Way To Engage Math-Haters
- Julia Steiny: Economy To Youth: Make Your Own Jobs
- Julia Steiny: Recess Is Good For Mental Health
- Julia Steiny: Best Beach Read—Paul Tough’s ‘How Children Succeed’
- Julia Steiny: Great Communities Are Happy, Healing Places
- Julia Steiny: Recruiting Family Before Foster Care
- Julia Steiny: Blackstone Valley Boasts a ‘Kick Butt’ School
- Julia Steiny: High-Stakes Testing Works If Kids Go To School
- Julia Steiny: The Importance of Having a Father
- Julia Steiny: Bloodlust For Boston Bombers Won’t Aid Healing
- Julia Steiny: If Only Congress Could Get A Divorce
- Julia Steiny: There Is No Health Without Mental Health
- Julia Steiny: Bring Back The ‘C’ Grade
- Julia Steiny: It’s Building Kids’ Vocabulary, Stupid
- Julia Steiny: We Are Raising A Generation Of Slackers
- Julia Steiny: Bringing Kids In Trouble Back From The Brink
- Julia Steiny: Middle-school Puberty–The Elephant in the Classroom
- Julia Steiny: What Mom Rats Can Teach Us About Child Rearing
- Julia Steiny: Careful What You Want & How You Measure Getting It
- Julia Steiny: Public Admits Being ‘Clueless’ About Education
- Julia Steiny: What The Numbers Tell Us About The Class of 2013