Massachusetts Among the Worst States For Retirees
Email to a friend
Permalink
Thursday, February 06, 2014
Zeke Wright, GoLocalWorcester Contributor
Massachusetts isn't particularly friendly toward retirees when it comes to taxes.
But with tax code changes and the state's “circuit breaker” credit for seniors, the environment has improved.
“Costs of living are obviously a huge consideration in deciding where to live or retire to,” according to Sandy Weiner, a state tax analyst for Wolters Kluwer, CCH. In a recent report detailing what they'll face during the upcoming tax season, Weiner says retirees should do their homework on the types of taxes they'd be responsible for paying before choosing where to retire.
Making those retirement savings last is key to post-employment bliss. The financial advice website Kiplinger puts Massachusetts as “not tax-friendly” for seniors, despite some breaks.
Black marks against the state include taxes on private pensions and estates and a comparatively high property tax burden.
“Massachusetts doesn't tax social security benefits, which is great, but it does tax pension income,” Weiner told GoLocal. “You also have to look at the tax rate applied.”
“And then you have to look at income in states and how far does it take you.”
Massachusetts' flat 5.25 percent income tax compares favorably for top earners to states with progressively scaled tax rates, but individuals and families in brackets just above exemption levels may pay more.
Of course, cost of living is only one determining factor for relocating retirees.
“They're not buried under 8 feet of snow,” Weiner says, describing her parents after their move from Chicago to warmer climes.
Mass. environment for retirees has improved
“It's not as bad as it used to be,” according to Barbara Anderson, executive director of the statewide group Citizens for Limited Taxation. But she said the longstanding reputation still hurt the state. “Years and years ago, Massachusetts was one of the worst states. ... Things have changed over the years.”
Anderson points to the state's Proposition 2 1/2, a successful ballot measure led by her group that began limiting year-over-year property tax increases in 1982.
“The property tax is the one that hurts retirees the most,” Anderson said. Still, given the economy and current unemployment, Anderson said she didn't see retirees in particularly worse shape than most residents.
“I never thought of senior citizens as different from taxpayers in general.”
Bay State property taxes in the top 10
The median property tax in Massachusetts was $3,511 in 2009, the most recent year provided in a comparison by the Washington, D.C.-based Tax Foundation. That amount ranked 6th in the nation but was partially driven up by comparatively high home values.
Looking at median property taxes as a percentage of income, residents in the Bay State paid 4.18 percent of their income — the 9th highest proportion in the country.
For residents 65 years or older, the state's circuit breaker program can provide a $1,000 property tax credit (with the surplus refundable for those who owe less in total payable income tax), but that discount only applies for principal residences for those under a certain income.
State taxes private pensions, estates over $1 million
In addition to general income, sales, and property taxes, retirees dependent on pensions should pay attention to how that income is taxed. Three states — Illinois, Mississippi, and Pennsylvania — exempt pension income entirely for qualified individuals. (That's in addition to the seven states that have no individual income tax, retirement or otherwise.)
Twenty-one other states offer a partial exemption, while Massachusetts is in the remainder that generally tax most pension income according to Wolters Kluwer, CCH.
However, the situation is not as bad for retirees as in a minority of states (including Rhode Island, Connecticut, and Vermont) that tax social security income.
More seniors entering retirement with debt
More seniors today are entering retirement carrying debt.
Using data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics' Consumer Expenditure Survey and the Federal Reserve Survey of Consumer Finances, the National Center for Policy Analysis finds the percentage of individuals ages 65 to 74 reporting a mortgage or home equity loan payment has increased from 21 percent in 1989 to 37 percent in 2010.
The percentage of individuals ages 75 and older with a home payment jumped from 6 percent to 21 percent during the same time, reflecting longer periods of principal mortgage debt.
Similarly, the average value of seniors' credit card balances are also up: to an average $6,000 in 2010 for 65 to 74 year olds and an average $4,600 for 75 year olds according to the NCPA.
Related Slideshow: Central Mass Schools with the Highest Graduation Rates
Glossary
Non-grad completers: Students that have successfully completed school according to local requirements, but whose MCAS test scores (scores lower than 220) prevent them from receiving an official diploma.
Students in cohort: Number of students eligible to graduate in 2013.
Prev
Next
41. Webster
Graduation rate: 69.7%
Dropout rate: 14.8%
Percent still in school: 7.7%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 142
Prev
Next
40. Southbridge
Graduation rate: 70.6%
Dropout rate: 16.8%
Percent still in school: 4.2%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 119
Prev
Next
39. Fitchburg (Tie)
Graduation rate: 71.6%
Dropout rate: 14%
Percent still in school: 9.6%
Percent non-grad completers: 1.8%
Number of students in cohort: 450
Prev
Next
38. Gardner (Tie)
Graduation rate: 71.6%
Dropout rate: 10.6%
Percent still in school: 14.9%
Percent non-grad completers: 1%
Number of students in cohort: 208
Prev
Next
37. Ralph C. Mahar
Graduation rate: 72.4%
Dropout rate: 13.2%
Percent still in school: 8.6%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 174
Prev
Next
36. Worcester
Graduation rate: 73.4%
Dropout rate: 11%
Percent still in school: 11.3%
Percent non-grad completers: 1.3%
Number of students in cohort: 1,885
Prev
Next
35. Athol-Royalston
Graduation rate: 77%
Dropout rate: 12%
Percent still in school: 5%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 100
Prev
Next
34. Oxford
Graduation rate: 78.5%
Dropout rate: 10.4%
Percent still in school: 7.6%
Percent non-grad completers: 1.4%
Number of students in cohort: 144
Prev
Next
33. Quaboag
Graduation rate: 78.8%
Dropout rate: 9.6%
Percent still in school: 7.7%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 104
Prev
Next
32. Northbridge
Graduation rate: 83.8%
Dropout rate: 5.6%
Percent still in school: 5%
Percent non-grad completers: 0.6%
Number of students in cohort: 179
Prev
Next
31. Berlin-Boylston
Graduation rate: 84.1%
Dropout rate: 7.9%
Percent still in school: 6.3%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 63
Prev
Next
30. Winchendon
Graduation rate: 84.5%
Dropout rate: 7.2%
Percent still in school: 6.2%
Percent non-grad completers: 1%
Number of students in cohort: 97
Prev
Next
29. North Brookfield
Graduation rate: 84.6%
Dropout rate: 5.1%
Percent still in school: 2.6%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 39
Prev
Next
28. Leicester
Graduation rate: 85%
Dropout rate: 5.3%
Percent still in school: 5.3%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 133
Prev
Next
27. Douglas
Graduation rate: 85.1%
Dropout rate: 8.9%
Percent still in school: 3%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 101
Prev
Next
26. Milford
Graduation rate: 86.5%
Dropout rate: 6.4%
Percent still in school: 5%
Percent non-grad completers: 0.4%
Number of students in cohort: 281
Prev
Next
25. Spencer-East Brookfield
Graduation rate: 87%
Dropout rate: 1.9%
Percent still in school: 5.6%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 108
Prev
Next
24. Uxbridge
Graduation rate: 87.8%
Dropout rate: 4.9%
Percent still in school: 4.1%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 123
Prev
Next
23. Clinton
Graduation rate: 88.5%
Dropout rate: 2.2%
Percent still in school: 2.9%
Percent non-grad completers: 1.4%
Number of students in cohort: 139
Prev
Next
22. Hudson
Graduation rate: 88.6%
Dropout rate: 5.9%
Percent still in school: 4.1%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 220
Prev
Next
21. Quabbin
Graduation rate: 88.7%
Dropout rate: 3.3%
Percent still in school: 5.7%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 212
Prev
Next
20. West Boylston
Graduation rate: 89.1%
Dropout rate: 3.1%
Percent still in school: 4.7%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 64
Prev
Next
19. Bellingham
Graduation rate: 89.6%
Dropout rate: 4.0%
Percent still in school: 2.9%
Percent non-grad completers: 1.7%
Number of students in cohort: 173
Prev
Next
18. Millbury
Graduation rate: 89.7%
Dropout rate: 4.3%
Percent still in school: 3.4%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 116
Prev
Next
17. Leominster
Graduation rate: 89.9%
Dropout rate: 3.8%
Percent still in school: 3.8%
Percent non-grad completers: 1.7%
Number of students in cohort: 477
Prev
Next
16. Blackstone-Millville
Graduation rate: 90.6%
Dropout rate: 5.4%
Percent still in school: 1.3%
Percent non-grad completers: 1.3%
Number of students in cohort: 149
Prev
Next
15. Wachusett
Graduation rate: 91.6%
Dropout rate: 2.5%
Percent still in school: 3.6%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 526
Prev
Next
14. Narragansett
Graduation rate: 91.9%
Dropout rate: 4.1%
Percent still in school: 2.4%
Percent non-grad completers: 0.8%
Number of students in cohort: 123
Prev
Next
13. Auburn
Graduation rate: 92.3%
Dropout rate: 4.1%
Percent still in school: 2.6%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 196
Prev
Next
12. Grafton
Graduation rate: 92.4%
Dropout rate: 1.8%
Percent still in school: 3.5%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 170
Prev
Next
11. Shrewsbury
Graduation rate: 92.8%
Dropout rate: 2.3%
Percent still in school: 2.1%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 432
Prev
Next
10. Tantasqua
Graduation rate: 93.1%
Dropout rate: 1.7%
Percent still in school: 3.4%
Percent non-grad completers: 0.3%
Number of students in cohort: 291
Prev
Next
9. Dudley-Charlton
Graduation rate: 93.6%
Dropout rate: 3%
Percent still in school: 2.6%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 265
Prev
Next
8. Ashburnham-Westminster
Graduation rate: 93.9%
Dropout rate: 2.4%
Percent still in school: 3%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 165
Prev
Next
7. Lunenburg
Graduation rate: 94.5%
Dropout rate: 0.8%
Percent still in school: 2.3%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 128
Prev
Next
6. Nashoba
Graduation rate: 94.7%
Dropout rate: 1.2%
Percent still in school: 2.4%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 247
Prev
Next
5. Mendon-Upton
Graduation rate: 95.2%
Dropout rate: 0.5%
Percent still in school: 3.2%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 189
Prev
Next
4. Hopedale
Graduation rate: 95.5%
Dropout rate: 1.1%
Percent still in school: 2.2%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 89
Prev
Next
3. Westborough
Graduation rate: 96.2%
Dropout rate: 0.8%
Percent still in school: 1.9%
Percent non-grad completers: 0.8%
Number of students in cohort: 265
Prev
Next
2. Northborough-Southborough
Graduation rate: 97.3%
Dropout rate: 0.3%
Percent still in school: 2.2%
Percent non-grad completers: 0.3%
Number of students in cohort: 364
Prev
Next
1. Harvard
Graduation rate: 97.4%
Dropout rate: 0.9%
Percent still in school: 1.7%
Percent non-grad completers: 0%
Number of students in cohort: 117
Related Articles
Enjoy this post? Share it with others.
Email to a friend
Permalink
Follow us on Pinterest Google + Facebook Twitter See It Read It