| | Advanced Search

 

NEW: Michael Graham Taking Conservative Talk Show to Atlanta—Headed for a warmer climate

NEW: Worcester’s Wormtown Brewery Wins Denver Int’l Beer Award—A major honor bestowed to a local brewery

Paul Giorgio: Elizabeth Warren is Right on Student Loans—MINDSETTER Paul Giorgio examines the student debt crisis

Central MA College Standout: Smith College’s Megan Baker—Spotlight on a bright student...

Organize + Energize: 7 Reasons to Hire a Professional Organizer—With a little help from your friends...

Rob Horowitz: The Civil Rights Act, 50 Years Later—Celebrating a milestone...

RE/MAX Reports 36.3% Increase in Pending MA Home Sales for March—Leading the region in pending home sales

College Admissions: 8 Ways Teens Can Explore Careers This Summer—Summer is the perfect time for students to…

Revs Return Home, Pick Up Crucial Win—The 2014 season had not started the way…

Monfredo: Worcester’s ‘City that Reads’ Book Drive Needs Your Help—Reading is a right, not a privilege

 
 

Walmart Pays Central Massachusetts Workers Less Than Costco

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

 

Wal-Mart employees get paid much less than they do at Costco.

When you think of low-paying jobs, you might think of Walmart and Costco. But in Massachusetts – and elsewhere across America – Costco beats Walmart hands down in what it pays to employees.

According to Payscale, the $470-billion Walmart – with 49 stores in Mass., including six in Worcester County - typically pays its U.S. workers 2 percent below the retail-store market average. The $97-billion Costco, on the other hand, typically pays its American employees 10 percent above that average. When it comes to health insurance, Walmart covers 70 percent of its American workers. At Costco, it’s 90 percent.

As CNBC reported last year, the average Costco wage nationwide is $20 per hour. As a result, CNBC noted at the time, Costco “has among the highest pay scales in the industry. … In reward, Costco has some of the lowest turnover rates in retail.” (Costco, which once had a Worcester location, has three Mass. stores. The one in Waltham is the closest to Worcester.)

In the Bay State, according to Walmart’s website, the average hourly wage for its 11,000 “regular, full-time hourly associates” is just above the low end of the living-wage range: $13.89, as of this July 31. The figure is for 30 discount stores and 17 supercenters in Mass. – including the supercenter along Route 146 in Worcester - and does not include the state’s two Sam’s Club stores.

Both locally and nationally, the “living wage” movement is fighting back - but to little avail. On September 6, 100 Walmart workers and activists in 11 U.S. cities were arrested as part of a national protest against the retail giant. Thousands of Walmart employees and labor activists in 15 U.S. cities participated in the protests. It was the largest action against Walmart since last November’s Black Friday's protests.

Both Walmart and a Clark University labor-relations expert contend that Walmart jobs – especially, entry-level ones – are good stepping stones for America’s unskilled and less-skilled workers. But that’s not stopping the living-wage movement. This November 29 - the day after Thanksgiving and the busiest shopping day of the year – they plan to mount what they call the biggest-ever U.S. strike against Walmart stores, including ones in Central Mass.

A living wage

The living-wage movement is seeking a 107 percent increase in the federal minimum wage - from $7.25 to $15 per hour. The last raise was in 2009.

Protesters have taken a stand against Walmart in Central Massachusetts... but what's changed?

By “living wage,” movement organizers mean $13.50 to $15 an hour. That’s the amount they say is required to enable one parent to earn enough money from a single 40-hour-per-week job to feed, cloth, educate, transport a family of four.

A recent Forbes article pulled no punches: Walmart Pays Workers Poorly And Sinks While Costco Pays Workers Well And Sails - Proof That You Get What You Pay For. “Here’s a crazy thought,” the article states. “Might it have something to do with the fact that Costco pays nearly all of its employees a decent living (well in excess of the minimum wage) while Wal-Mart continues to pay its workers as if their employees don’t actually need to eat more than once a week, live in an enclosed space and, on occasion, take their kids to see a doctor?”

Walmart has yet to respond to a GoLocalWorcester interview request. Last December, though, Walmart CEO Mike Duke defended the wages his company pays its workforce - which numbers 2.2 million worldwide and 1.4 million in the U.S.

Duke, according to Business Insider, pointed out that that retail is a lower-margin industry in general, and that Walmart's wages are competitive. "Retailing is the most competitive industry out there, and we do pay competitive wages," he said. "Last year, we promoted 165,000 people from entry-level to managerial positions."

Gary Chaison, professor of industrial relations at Clark University, points out that the protest numbers are quite small compared with Walmart’s global workforce. "You're not seeing two million workers joining the movement,” he tells GoLocalWorcester. “Many are just happy to have their job."

The protests, according to Chaison, show that unions ‘‘still can appeal to and speak for workers who are on the fringes of the workforce — the less skilled, the part-timers, and the immigrant workers.” Much of this labor force comprises the 11.5 million – officially, at least - people who are unemployed nationwide, which is nearly double the number prior to the Great Recession.

The pay that Walmart’s Mass. workers receive is quite comparable to the rest of the country, according to Chaison. “The argument that’s been made against Walmart in terms of low pay doesn’t really stand up very well because Walmart tends to have very low pay for entry-level workers,” he says. “But those workers quickly advance to more moderate levels of pay.”

Chaison think Walmart is getting “generally a bad rap.” That, he adds, is because the retail chain “provides something that most people don’t find in alternative types of employment, and that is part-time or temporary jobs. … And the only other alternative is fast-food places. So to some degree, they provide alternative employment for people who might not otherwise be employed.” Walmart also provides affordable shopping outlets, he adds, “for people who can buy things that they would not otherwise be able to pay [for] because Walmart prices tend to be low.” This, he says, enables lower-income consumers, including those who work at Walmart, to make purchases they couldn’t otherwise afford, such as appliances, which “really increases their standard of living.”

Chaison thinks that if a large enough number of Walmart workers felt strongly enough that they were being mistreated, the living-wage protest lines outside Walmart stores “would be much larger.” If Walmart and other big-box retailers are forced to pay living wages to their workers, he notes, either consumers would subsidize the added cost or the chains’ bottom lines would need to shrink. And that latter effect, he says, “might affect their stocks, which are held by a lot of pensioners.”

Still, Chaison says the idea that “no worker in America should be employed and still be below the poverty level makes a lot of sense.” But that needs to be addressed as a national public-policy issue, he acknowledges, instead of beating up on Walmart.

“Walmart is the company that everyone loves to hate,” Chaison says. “The reason that it’s such a convenient punching bag is that the dislike of Walmart is so broadly shared by people who are against globalization for whatever reason, and by people who see [Walmart] as a major non-union employer and think it should be unionized, and by people who believe that Walmart destroys downtowns and small villages.” In the end, Chaison says, “all power lies in the hands of the consumer,” who continue to shop at Walmart.

Grace Ross, a Worcester-based community organizer and founder of The Grace Team, is a former board member of the Mass. chapter of Jobs With Justice. She works closely with that chapter, which is organizing ChangeWalmartMA and has yet to respond to GoLocalWorcester’s requests for an interview.

Ross, a GoLocalWorcester MINDSETTER, welcomes Walmart to join the fight for a national public policy that guarantees a living wage for all working Americans. “I don’t think anybody would oppose Walmart joining forces with the rest of us to create a decent floor for wages in this country,” she says.

That said, Ross doesn’t expect Walmart to take up that challenge any time soon. After the retail chain got a since-expired break on Mass. taxes several years ago, she recalls, it hired lobbyists to kill an expansion of the tax break to other Bay State industries.

“When Walmart’s been approached about making an industry-wide change that would be fairer, they’ve opted to be on the other side,” Ross says. “I think it’s their opportunity to step forward for once and say, ‘Yes, we’re going to work with people to fix an industry- or market-wide problem.'” (See today’s MINDSETTER by Ross on Walmart and one woman's story.)

A thinly spread workforce

 Walmart could be paying a price for the way it runs its business. Witness a March article in Bloomberg Businessweek, Walmart Faces the Cost of Cost-Cutting: Empty Shelves.

“Wal-Mart Stores … has been cutting staff since the recession—and pallets of merchandise are piling up in its stockrooms as shelves go unfilled,” the article reported. In the past five years, the article noted, the world’s largest retailer added 455 U.S. Walmart stores, a 13 percent increase, according to company filings last January. In the same period, Walmart’s total U.S. workforce, which includes employees at its Sam’s Club warehouse stores, dropped by about 20,000, or 1.4 percent.

“A thinly spread workforce has other consequences,” the article continued, “including longer checkout lines, less help throughout the store, and disorganization.” In February, the article noted, Walmart placed last among department and discount stores in the annual American Customer Satisfaction Index, the sixth year in a row the company has either tied or taken the last spot. “The dwindling level of customer service,” the article reports, “comes as Walmart has touted its in-store experience to lure financially strained shoppers and to counter the threat from online rivals such as Amazon.com.”

Chaison, of Clark University, agrees that “there’s some level of dissatisfaction among customers at Walmart. I think Walmart’s problem is that they’ve just been expanding so fast that they’ve had trouble controlling the process.” Together, Walmart and Sam’s Club have experienced explosive U.S. growth in recent decades, as depicted in a 2010 FlowingData presentation.

“Let’s face it,” Chaison says, “if Walmart was an operation that had three stores, all of its [stores’ performance] figures would be a lot better.”

Steven Jones-D'Agostino is chief pilot of Best Rate of Climb: Marketing, Public Relations, Social Media and Radio Production. Follow him on Twitter @SteveRDAgostino.
 

 

Related Articles

 

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.

Comments:

Iron Mike Farquhar

It is NOT the role of either the press or of government to set working conditions, wages, or staffing levels.

Well,...it is under a national socialist form of government, - but we thought we solved THAT problem in 1945.

If Walmart underpays or under-staffs, then THEY take the risks – NOT YOU! If you don't like what they're doing – don't shop there. Start your own store.

Steven Jones-DAgostino

I believe it is the role of the press to investigate and expose legitimate and valid charges of abusive private-sector working conditions, wages and/or staffing levels. That way, readers will know whether or not they want to continue using a particular business or organization. Once they're aware of the abuses -- or alleged abuses - it's up to them to decide whether or not to continue doing business with those places.

Edward Saucier

That's old news and for the heck of it look at their stock prices.

Of course the NLRA went into effect decades ago. That's an effort to bring Mikey up to speed. In fact Germany was a fascist state during WWII not a socialist state. There is a big difference.

The USA is pretty much run by the corporatists now and that old fascist Mussolini said there's no difference between the two and he should know. However, Mike's not big on facts. The good side is that we still have a little socialism hanging on.

Iron Mike Farquhar

Socialism Ed, is a system designed by career low-achievers so they could enjoy the lifestyles of entrepreneurs and skilled working men.

And Ed, the Germans under Hitler were governed by the National Sozialistiche Deutsche Arbeitpartei (NSDAP) which in English means National Socialist German Workers Party.

“Fascism” refers to the brutal tactics used to emplace the desired political structures. If you resisted you were beaten, - if you resisted the following day, - you were taken 'away'.

With all due respect for your fondness for other people’s' hard-earned money Ed, - you'll never be able to 'bring me up to speed'.

Edward Saucier

Atta boy MIke, keep that thought. Another clod who believes what Hitler said. And has no compassion for those not as fortunate as others and would rater have them thrown on a trash pile to die. You're a real fine American Mikey - as they say.

All our presidents called the USA a democracy and we're nothing but. We overthrow countries who become democratic and replace the leaders with our puppets. The USA is all about controlling the world through force and fear. The same thing Hitler did. Eventually we will meet the same fate as nothing lasts forever.

So what's wrong with paying people a fair days wage for a fair days work while we await our destiny?

Dave Flynn

WalMart has always wrapped their greedy asses in the American Flag and the propaganda they spew about a better quality of life is pretty sickening when you think about the quality of life the WalMart employee has. Lots of people bad mouth the corporation, yet probably run down to the local WalMart to buy materials for the protest signs! Boycott the bastards!




Commenting is not available in this channel entry.