Worcester Schools Burdened By Costly Tech Upgrades
Wednesday, January 22, 2014
Spurred by the adoption of Common Core State Standards and the core-aligned, computer-based test Massachusetts is set to adopt, the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC), public school districts in the Commonwealth are being required to add growing technology purchases to their spending plans.
What's driving education's technological shift?
“There are a number of drivers, including the move to Common Core education standards, which emphasize computer literacy,” according to Lisa Guisbond, executive director of Citizens for Public Schools, a statewide nonprofit based in Boston.
“Rapid obsolescence is a big and perhaps under-acknowledged issue in all this,” responded Guisbond when queried. She said it was certainly worth questioning the logic behind further technological adoption while teaching staff were laid off around the state and nation.
Replacing decade-old computers a requirement
For the current fiscal year 2014, the Worcester Public Schools committee agreed last fall to a five-year lease plan that replaces all 7,400 computers in the district at an annual cost of $1.2 million.
The next immediate technology hurdle is getting wireless connectivity into every school building.
“Because of the budget challenges we've faced over the past several years, we haven't invested as much in technology as we could have, and probably should have,” said committee member Jack Foley, chair of the finance and operations standing committee.
Through recent budgetary shortfalls, Foley said preserving teaching staff and course offerings had come at the expense of technology and physical facility improvements. That's being corrected now, he said.
“We had no choice but to upgrade and spend that money,” Foley said of the computer upgrade lease plan, which puts the school on a flexible five-year replacement cycle.
Information Technology Officer Bob Walton said the school district made do through years of decreased funding by purchasing refurbished computers.
But given Microsoft's end of support for Windows XP this April, Walton said the district needed to act. More than three quarters of the school's desktop computers were running XP. “In addition, the computers in the district were 10-plus years old in some cases,” Walton added.
Adding wireless connectivity and bandwidth are the next items on the agenda in terms of technology improvements for Worcester. The district is midway through its current three-year technology plan.
“The PARCC test is coming down the pipe and districts need to be prepared for it,” Walton said.
The computer-based PARCC test, billed as a more comprehensive assessment of students' learning, is slated for implementation in 19 states and will replace current paper tests like the Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System.
But computers and their infrastructure are more costly than outgoing No. 2 pencils.
Walton said the online test would require more Internet and network bandwidth than schools currently have available. Annual costs to upgrade each throughout the district total $22,000 and $67,000, respectively, after reimbursement through a federal subsidy program known as E-Rate.
While some federal revenue sources like E-Rate exist, state technology entitlement grants ceased several years ago.
Furthermore, 14 school buildings currently do not have building-wide wireless coverage. “There are several problems with the wireless in the district's schools, even in the buildings that have building-wide wireless coverage,” according to Walton, who said most of the technology was approaching the 10-year mark.
Agreement on tech's value in 21st century
Administrators are recommending an additional $565,000 annual allocation to complete “high density” building-wide coverage in all schools. Walton said the impact would “transform the way students and staff can interact with technology.”
Foley said committee members were consciously trying to enhance learning in the classroom. “We have tried to target money for technology that can be used in the classroom appropriately,” Foley said.
“Technology can be something of a black hole” if not purchased wisely, he added.
“Twenty-first century schools need both up-to-date technology and quality professional development for teachers,” responded Paul Toner, president of the Massachusetts Teachers Association, the statewide union and affiliate of the National Education Association and local Educational Association of Worcester. “In the digital era, how teachers teach and how and what students learn is greatly affected by technology. Students who aren't computer-literate when they graduate from high school will be left behind when they go to college or get a job.”
Guisbond said there was widespread recognition of an economic “digital divide” putting low-income students at a disadvantage at school and at home.
“So there is a lot of attention being paid to ensuring that K-12 students have access to various forms of technology in school,” she said. “The move to online Common Core (e.g., PARCC) testing, however, is a particularly big, immediate and controversial driver.”
After debate last November over the assessment changeover at the state board of education, Massachusetts has adopted a two-year transition plan to the PARCC exams.
Guisbond said her organization believes there needs to be a focus on providing equitable access to a well-rounded education meeting the needs of the whole child.
“I think that there is already too much time, money and attention spent on standardized testing in our schools, with little to show for it in terms of moving toward greater equity of access and outcomes,” she said. In other words, affluent students continue to do well while poor students, those with disabilities, and English language learners continue to struggle.
“I am far from convinced that new PARCC, computer-based tests will be worth the added investment and I am concerned that they will actually add to the time spent on testing and test preparation when what we need is a shift away from our current nationwide obsession with standardized testing.“
Bridging the digital divide or heightening it?
“There is a strong case to be made that investment in school technology is a way to address the digital divide and give low-income students access to technology,” Guisbond says. “On the other hand, technology is no substitute for trained staff, including teachers, social workers, school psychologists and librarians, who are increasingly facing the axe in many hard-hit districts.”
With school resources stretched thin, “I think you need to question whether spending millions of dollars on computer access and upgrades should be the priority.”
Related Slideshow: Highest Paid Teachers in Central MA
- John Monfredo: Reassessing Parent Involvement in Our Schools
- The Most and Least Diverse High Schools in Central MA
- In Case You Missed It: New England’s Top Public High Schools
- John Monfredo: Adult Learning A Worcester Public Schools Treasure
- New England’s Top 50 Public High Schools: Massachusetts Runners-Up
- The Top High Schools in Massachusetts 2013
- Mount Wachusett CC Hosts Green Schools Conference
- The Top High Schools in Central Massachusetts 2013
- Leading Central MA: Worcester Public Schools’ Robert Jennings
- Reaction to Top High Schools in Central Massachusetts 2013
- In Case You Missed It: The Worst Behaved Schools in MA
- The Worst Behaved Schools in MA
- How White Is Your School: The Most Diverse High Schools in MA
- The Top 50 Most Diverse Public High Schools in MA
- NEW: Worcester and Fitchburg Schools Closed
- Worcester Schools Spend $500 Less Per Student Than Mass. Average
- John Monfredo: Worcester Schools Expand Breakfast/Supper Programs
- John Monfredo: Worcester Schools Launch Attendance Campaign
- NEW: Gov. Patrick Seeks Nominees for Green Ribbon Schools Award