Arthur Schaper: Free Justina, Now!
Friday, April 11, 2014
The Massachusetts Department of Children and Families has now taken “permanent” custody of young Justina, meaning that they decide when she can go home with her parents.
Slate Magazine summarized the first clash between parent and government-hospital:
When her father tried to have her discharged to take her back to Tufts, the Boston Globe reports, “he watched a swarm of hospital security approach to guard each exit.” The hospital “filed an allegation of medical child abuse” against the couple for seeking what the hospital deemed as “unnecessary treatment” and petitioned the state for custody.
A sad and scary tale, indeed.
While waiting indefinitely (and inexorably) for the day they can take their daughter home, the Pelletier parents can only visit their daughter and call her once a week. Some of the professionals are disputing whether the parents are causing the daughter’s mental problems. Allegations of medical abuse – Munchausen’s by proxy, for example – do not negate the fact that while the symptoms of Justina’s illness resist clear diagnosis, that is no excuse for the state of Massachusetts to hold the Pelletier’s daughter indefinitely.
One Massachusetts resident shared with me his outrage about Beacon Hill’s inaction:
The governor now says he can't do anything to help her, Baloney!
State police are investigating threats against the hospital and staff because of this case, but nothing regarding the hospital’s overreach into this family’s plight. The Massachusetts Department of Children and Families has stirred up so much controversy, that no other agency will intervene.
A few issues come to mind when evaluating at this tragic case.
1. At what point does the state have the authority to trump parental rights?
After fourteen months, Massachusetts has not presented a compelling case that Justina’s parents have abused their child. Granted, the welfare of a child in immediate danger should not force legal authorities to follow bureaucratic protocols. Still, emergency injunctions should be challenged in a timely manner. Fourteen months is too long.
2. What role does Obamacare play in this debacle?
Instead of medical professions, key health care decisions are falling under the purview of the government. The IRS enforces individuals to purchase health insurance or pay a fine. At what point will the state exchanges start picking winners and losers, i.e. which patients receive necessary treatment or a staggered hospice with death to follow?
A state hospital, with the power of the judicial powers that be, has forced a sick young lady to endure privations in a psych ward and deteriorate. These very circumstances should infuriate anyone with authority whether legal or moral in the Commonwealth.
And the above allegations beg the next question:
3. Why has this aggravated usurpation of power received so little press in the media?
The same breakdown in political accountability in Rhode Island (complaisant media with a complacent electorate) does not bear out in Massachusetts, at least regarding individual outrage about Justina’s plight. Facebook has a Free Justina Now page and A Miracle for Justina site, too.
Regarding a complaisant media, one news commentator, former Arkansas Governor and Presidential candidate Mike Huckabee spotlighted this case. With terse words for “The People’s Republic of Massachusetts”, Huckabee has criticized the DCF repeatedly, and then recently reported:
A spokesman from the Massachusetts Department of Children and Families specifically asked me to correct three things --
Number one: that the state kidnapped the girl.
Number two: that no evidence has ever been presented to support abuse or neglect.
And number three: that the state never conducted an investigation or spoke with the family.
Huckabee offered to set the record straight, but the state of Massachusetts has held onto the girl for fourteen months, and the state holds the conflicting arguments that the parents are not fit parents, yet at the same time they want to return to the child to her parents: a real yet scary and confusing scenario.
Despite the legal back-and-forth stalling any resolution on this matter, the state legislature has just introduced a bill, HD4212, which would allow Justina to go home. This bill could be passed in one day.
The Legislature has the ultimate authority to act on this. It has the constitutional power to free Justina. And it could get it done very quickly - if it chooses to.
Refusing to sit by while Beacon Hill does nothing, and “Mister Governor” Deval Patrick’s silence gives tacit approval to Justina’s involuntary confinement, pro-family activists have stepped up grassroots efforts to #FreeJustina.
Visit this link to find a copy of the one-page bill which Justina supporters are bringing to their representatives. Rep. Lenny Mirra (R-West Newbury) has already filed a bill “by request”, but the reticence of liberal lawmakers to upset Patrick, and Republicans to disturb the desired quiescence of the minority leadership (plus concerns about relation from judges and public employee interests).
Once again, it is within the power of Massachusetts residents, with channeled outrage over this tragic case, to make Beacon Hill listen and free Justina Pelletier.
Arthur Christopher Schaper is a teacher-turned-writer on topics both timeless and timely; political, cultural, and eternal. A life-long Southern California resident, Arthur currently lives in Torrance. Follow him on Twitter @ArthurCSchaper, reach him at [email protected], and read more at Schaper's Corner and As He Is, So Are We Ministries.
Related Slideshow: Preventable Deaths in American Hospitals
To Err is Human
In 1999 the Institute of Medicine published the bombshell “To Err Is Human” report, which revealed that up to 98,000 people a year die because of mistakes in hospitals. Though initially disputed, the report is now widely accepted by doctors and hospital officials, including RI Dept. of Health Director Dr. Michael Fine.
Health and Human Services
In 2010, the Office of Inspector General for Health and Human Services said that bad hospital care contributed to the deaths of 180,000 patients in Medicare alone in a given year.
Journal of Patient Safety
In 2013, the Journal of Patient Safety published research that claims the number of preventable deaths may be much higher — between 210,000 and 440,000 patients each year who go to the hospital for care suffer some type of preventable harm that contributes to their death. That's roughly one-sixth of all deaths in the United States each year.
Dr. Peter Pronovost, Johns Hopkins Medicine’s senior vice president for patient safety and quality, has developed a scientifically proven method for reducing the deadly infections associated with central line catheters. His simple but effective checklist protocol virtually eliminated these infections across the state of Michigan, saving 1,500 lives and $100 million annually.
- Arthur Christopher Schaper: Gabriel Gomez–An Anti-Tribute
- Arthur Schaper: ‘Saint’ Patrick’s Budget Proposals For Mass.
- Arthur Schaper: Fattman: Obamacare-Less in MA
- Arthur Schaper: James McGovern(ment) Comes To Worcester
- Arthur Schaper: Massachusetts Needs Governor Bradford or Coolidge
- Arthur Schaper: The Real Reason New England is So Liberal
- Arthur Christopher Schaper: Mass. GOP–Don’t Be Dead, Dude!
- Arthur Schaper: AdamsCare, RomneyCare, ObamaCare: Bad Healthcare
- Arthur Schaper: Frank Addivinola for US Senate (For Real)
- Arthur Schaper: Live Free, Live Long, Win Big, MA GOP
- Arthur Schaper: Mind Your Own Business, Mister Governor
- Arthur Schaper: Two Peters To End the Petering Out of Mass GOP
- Arthur Christopher Schaper: Top 10 Quotes From Ed Markey
- Arthur Schaper: Another Special Election In Massachusetts! (Meh)
- Arthur Schaper: Gimme Five, Addivinola!
- Arthur Schaper: MA Politicians and Doctors Behaving Badly
- Arthur Schaper: Politics: A Matter of the Heart
- Arthur Schaper: Victimless Crimes in the Bay State
- Arthur Christopher Schaper: What Happened to the Northeast GOP?
- Arthur Schaper: Anti-Tribute to James “Whitey” Bulger
- Arthur Schaper: Gomez, The Globe + Guns
- Arthur Schaper: MA’s Health Care Most Costly: Duh!
- Arthur Schaper: Progressive Elizabeth Warren For President?
- Arthur Schaper: What Would Senator Brooke Say, Mister Governor?
- Arthur C. Schaper: Adams + Obama—A Match Made In Heaven!
- Arthur Christopher Schaper: What’s The Matter With Massachusetts?
- Arthur Schaper: Brian Herr for US Senate (Who’s He?)
- Arthur Schaper: Holiday Blues in the Bay State
- Arthur Schaper: Mark Inman for US Senate (Really?!)
- Arthur Schaper: Schooling Massachusetts’ Governor on ABCs of EBTs
- Arthur Schaper: X-Mas, The C-Word in Massachusetts
- Arthur C. Schaper: Dad: I Am A Massachusetts Liberal! (*Yawn*)
- Arthur Christopher Schaper: Where Do You Stay, Markey?
- Arthur Schaper: Computers, Pledges + Syria in Massachusetts
- Arthur Schaper: How the GOP Can Run for Congress (and Win) in MA
- Arthur Schaper: Markey-Gomez: Can A ‘Different’ Republican Win?
- Arthur Schaper: Senator Markey Leaves His Mark
- Schaper: Fisher, Baker, and Democratic Takers
- Arthur C. Schaper: MA GOP Takes Down Tax (Dems, Not So Much)
- Arthur Schaper: “Mister Governor” Patrick’s Final Budget
- Arthur Schaper: Death and Execution in Massachusetts
- Arthur Schaper: Immigration Issues in Massachusetts
- Arthur Schaper: Markey: Missing the Mark on ObamaCare
- Arthur Schaper: Stand Your Ground, Connecticut!
- Schaper: Is Free Speech Petering Out In New England?
- Arthur C. Schaper: Washington Sucks
- Arthur Schaper: “Raise Up Massachusetts” Brings Bay State Down
- Arthur Schaper: Dr. Seuss Votes for Climate Change?
- Arthur Schaper: It’s Pirate Time, GOP!
- Arthur Schaper: Mass GOP Takes On Forever Gas Tax
- Arthur Schaper: Takers Get Taken, Makers Make It