Paul Giorgio: What Is at the Core of the Common Core Dispute?
Wednesday, March 19, 2014
The local fight is being led by former School Committee member Donna Colorio. Colorio served a single term on the School Committee and was defeated last November, when the voters of Worcester realized she was affiliated with the Tea Party.
There is a growing cadre of people who are anti-science, anti- medicine and anti- change. Whether we are talking about climate change or the history of mankind or the immunization of children against preventable childhood diseases, there is an element in our society and community who are against it all. They see all of this this all as an intrusion on their lives.
I even heard one gentleman call a local talk radio show, decrying “Government schools." I don’t even know what that means.
The Worcester School Committee has been debating Common Core for a few weeks now, ever since Worcester was chosen as a test site for the new test.
The right wing argument
The Educational Association of Worcester—the Worcester teacher's union—also had a vote of no confidence in the tests implementation, according to reports in the local media. Of course the teacher’s unions also opposed the MCAS, when they were first proposed.
The primary argument used before the Worcester School Committee this past month was that “Parents wanted to retain control over their children's education and that they did not want their students being used as “lab rats," according to one parent by taking a test to determine the assessment’s legitimacy and accuracy."
I don’t get it. Do they think that the child will be damaged by taking the test?
First of all, parents have never had direct control over their children’s education unless they were home schooled. If you had “direct” parental control, you could end up with a different set of standards and curriculum for each school. Education has always been in the purview of the government. That is why we have laws that mandate children must attend school until they are sixteen.
Changing with the times
If we want to be on the cutting edge, we must change with the times. We must always improve what we are doing and how we are doing it. This applies to education as well as science and math and engineering
What Common Core does is create a unified approach to education. This Common Core was developed by educators and parents and the Governors of our states. Those Governors were both Republicans and Democrats and Liberals and Conservatives. This is not a top down but a bottom up approach to creating a common set of standards. It also replaces one of the last relics of George W. Bush’s Presidency and that is No Child Left Behind. The sad fact was that plenty of children were left behind.
According to School Committee member and GoLocal contributor John Monfredo:
“It is interesting to note that 90% of the math and English Language Arts Common Core Standards come from the Massachusetts Frameworks.”
The goal of Common Core is to prepare America’s students for jobs in the 21st century workforce. Jobs that are so very different from when I was in high school and then college.
The right wing, who don’t want their children used as” lab rats” are quite content to use them as pawns in what they perceive as a political fight over ideology.
Paul Giorgio is a longtime Democratic Party Activist who has worked on numerous campaigns. He was a Lead Advance Person for President Clinton & Vice President Gore. He was Deputy Director of Special Events for President Clinton’s first Inauguration. He has been elected a delegate to numerous Democratic National Conventions and recently served as one of President Obama’s representatives on the Platform Committee. In 2013 he was chosen as a Presidential Elector. He is the President of Pagio, Inc., publishers of Pulse Magazine, Vitality Magazine and Worcester Medicine.
Related Slideshow: Central Mass Schools with the Highest Graduation Rates
Non-grad completers: Students that have successfully completed school according to local requirements, but whose MCAS test scores (scores lower than 220) prevent them from receiving an official diploma.
Students in cohort: Number of students eligible to graduate in 2013.
- Paul Giorgio: Food Trucks Don’t Save Cities
- Paul Giorgio: Massachusetts Needs To Reform Its Gun Laws
- Paul Giorgio: Scott Brown: Desperately Seeking Relevance
- Paul Giorgio: The State of Disunity
- Paul Giorgio: For Scott Brown, it’s Strike Three
- Paul Giorgio: Obamacare, The Debt Ceiling + Tea Party Republicans
- Paul Giorgio: Scott Brown: To Be or Not to Be
- Paul Giorgio: We Have Too Many Not-for-Profits
- Paul Giorgio: Free Speech vs. Crazy Talk
- Paul Giorgio: Raise the Min. Wage, But Leave Restaurants Out of It
- Paul Giorgio: Should Worcester Look at Electing a Strong Mayor?
- Paul Giorgio: What I Learned From The Government Shutdown
- Paul Giorgio: GOP’s Rising Stars Need New Ideas
- Paul Giorgio: Republicans Hit A New Low
- Paul Giorgio: Syria Redux
- Paul Giorgio: Why Ed Augustus Would Be a Great City Manager
- Paul Giorgio: I Don’t Give a Duck!
- Paul Giorgio: Republicans Need To End Discrimination In Workforce
- Paul Giorgio: Tea Party Turning US Into A Banana Republic
- Paul Giorgio: Will Bridgegate Cost Christie the GOP Nod in 2016?
- Paul Giorgio: Is There Really a War on Christmas?
- Paul Giorgio: Roger Ailes, A Bully with a Bully Pulpit
- Paul Giorgio: The Biggest Political Winners and Losers in 2013
- Paul Giorgio: World Cop or World Conscience In Syria?
- Paul Giorgio: JFK’s Assassination Through The Eyes of a Child
- Paul Giorgio: Romney Re-Emerges
- Paul Giorgio: The Handshake Heard Around the World
- Paul Giorgio: Ed Augustus Has the Leadership Qualities We Need
- Paul Giorgio: Making Worcester the Healthiest City in New England
- Paul Giorgio: Scott Brown is Sarah Palin in a Suit
- Paul Giorgio: The Real EBT Scammers Are the Vendors, Not the Poor