Dispatches from the Rio Olympics from Professor Victor Matheson - Economic Benefits
Email to a friend
Permalink
Friday, August 12, 2016
Prof. Victor Matheson
Rio certainly comes into this Olympics facing numerous challenges ranging from security and pollution as discussed in previous posts to political unrest, a severe recession, and the Zika virus. But spanning across all of these is a specific worry: will the economic benefits generated from the event be sufficient to pay for Brazil's $13 billion investment in the Games.
Economists have painted an increasingly dim picture of the wisdom of investing in mega-events like the Olympics and World Cup as method to promote economic development. The cost of hosting these events now routinely runs into the tens of billions of dollars. Athens spent about $11 billion in 2004, an amount that was huge at the time but seems almost quaint now. The seemingly most unbeatable world record set in Beijing in 2008 was not by Michael Phelps in the pool, but by the organizing committee who spent $45 billion. Of course records are meant to be broken and Russia and Vladimir Putin did it back in 2014 by spending $51 billion in Sochi. Qatar's upcoming World Cup in 2022 might go as high as $200 billion.
But it doesn't have to be this way. Los Angeles held the entire 1984 Summer Games at a cost of less than the $2 billion price tag of just Tokyo's new Olympic stadium being built for 2020. So what has happened to the economic model to cause such runaway spending?
The clear culprit here is the International Olympic Committee. When Los Angeles hosted in 1984, they were the only bidder for the games and could dictate the terms of the bid to the IOC. They used existing sport facilities and minimized other costs. With large infusions of private investment and minimized costs, the L.A. Games managed a respectable profit of over $100 million. But following the successful 1984 event, cities began to line up to bid, and faced with multiple bidders, the IOC has been back in the driver's seat ever since. Thus cities not only have to worry about accommodating all of the events but also presenting a lavish enough bid to beat out the competition.
And it's not just about the facilities but also event management. Last year public support for Norway's 2022 Winter Olympics bid collapsed when details about the IOC's demands for the bid became public. These included expensive perks for executive committee members topped off with a required cocktail party with the royal family to be paid for by the local taxpayers.
I witnessed a perfect example of the hubris of IOC last week at the opening match of the men's soccer tournament between Algeria and Honduras. Officially the game was sold out and the local organizers had stopped selling tickets. But thousands of seats were reserved for IOC officials which went unused and unsold. Roughly $100,000 of ticket revenue in that match alone went uncollected on the off chance that IOC President Thomas Bach and a couple thousand of his best friends might show up for the game.
Those fans who got in, including me thanks to a friendly Argentinian fan with an extra ticket, were treated to an exciting 3-2 win for Honduras and got to see the best of the Olympic spirit on display. But the blocks of empty seats were a testament to the worst of the Olympic spirit as well.
Victor Matheson is a professor in the Department of Economics and Accounting at the College of the Holy Cross. He specializes in the economics of sports stadiums and mega-events. Frequently quoted in the press, he has been appeared on NPR, CNN, and in the New York Times, Washington Post, Boston Globe, and of course various GoLocal sites. He is currently president-elect of the North American Association of Sport Economics as well as the editor of the Journal of Sports Economics.
Related Slideshow: The Greatest Massachusetts Olympic Hockey Players
Prev
Next
Jonathan Quick
Olympic Teams: 2010, 2014
A graduate of University of Massachusetts Amherst, Quick is the goaltender for the current U.S. men’s hockey team in Sochi. Quick, who is the goaltender for the Los Angeles Kings, won a silver medal with the United States at the 2010 Winter Games in Vancouver.
Considered one of the best goaltenders in the NHL, Quick was named the MVP of the. 2012 Stanley Cup Playoffs. In 2012, he set an NHL record winning 11 consecutive road games behind the net.
Prev
Next
Alex Carpenter
Olympic Team: 2014
At just 19-years-old, Carpenter is the youngest of Massachusetts’ 10 athletes competing at the 2014 Winter Olympics in Sochi. The daughter of former NHL player Bobby Carpenter, she currently plays forward for Boston College. In fact, Carpenter was the Turfer Athletic Hockey East scoring champion last year and finished seventh overall in the nation with 1.89 points per game.
Despite her young age, Carpenter has won a pair of gold medals so far on the international stage – one at the 2013 Women’s World Championships in Canada, and another at the 2011 IIHF World Women’s U18 Championship in Sweden.
Prev
Next
Bill Guerin
Olympic Teams: 1998, 2002, 2006
Born in Worcester, this NHL Hall of Famer represented the United States in the Olympics in 1998, 2002, and 2006 – winning a silver medal in 2002. Raised in Wilbraham, Guerin graduated high school from Wilbraham & Monson Academy and is a alumni of Boston College.
Guerin played an impressive 18 seasons in the NHL, winning a pair of Stanley Cup titles in 2002 and 2006 as a member of the New Jersey Devils and the Pittsburgh Penguins.
Prev
Next
Kevin Shattenkirk
Olympic Team: 2014
A graduate of Boston University, this St. Louis Blues defensemen is currently representing the United States at the Winter Olympics in Sochi. Shattenkirk enjoyed a successful collegiate career with the Terriers – being named to the All-Hockey East Rookie Team in 2007-2008 season and the All-Hockey East Second team in 2008-2009. He was also named a NCAA East Second Team All-American in the 2008-2009 season.
Prev
Next
Kacey Bellamy
Olympic Teams: 2010, 2014
Born in Westfield, Bellamy played for the U.S. women’s hockey team in Vancouver and is representing the U.S. once again in Sochi. A graduate of Berkshire School, she was named Berkshire’s Female Athlete of the Year in her junior and senior year.
In addition to being named to two Olympic teams, Bellamy is a two-time member of the U.S. Women’s National Team and a three-time member of the U.S. Women’s Select Team.
Prev
Next
Jeremy Roenick
Olympic Team: 1998
Considered one of the best professional hockey players of his generation, represented the United States at the 1998 Olympic Games in Nagano. Born in Boston, Roenick played prep hockey at Thayer Academy in Braintree. After college, he would go on to play 18 seasons in the NHL. Elected to the NHL Hamm of Fame in 2010, Roenick is one of four American-born players to score 500 career goals.
Prev
Next
Justin McCarthy
Olympic Team: 1924
Born in Charlestown, McCarthy was the captain of the U.S. men’s hockey team that won the silver medal at the 1924 Winter Olympics in Chamonix, France. He was a member of the Boston Athletics Association, a non-profit sports association for the city of Boston.
Prev
Next
Keith Tkachuk
Olympic Teams: 1992, 1998, 2002, 2006
This former NHL All-Star represented the United States in four Olympic Games in 1992, 1998, 2002, and 2006 – winning a silver medal in 2002. Born in Melrose, Tkachuk began his hockey career at Malden Catholic High School and would go on to play collegiately at Boston University.
Tkachuk is one of four American-born players to score 500 goals in a career, and one just six Americans to score 1,000 NHL points.
Prev
Next
Ryan Whitney
Olympic Team: 2010
This Scituate native won a silver medal as a member of the 2010 U.S. Men’s Hockey Team in Vancouver. He began his hockey career playing for Thayer Academy in Braintree and would go on to play for Boston University. Whitney currently plays defenseman for the Florida Panthers.
Prev
Next
Donald Rigazio
Olympic Team: 1956
This former IHL goaltender won a silver medal as a member of the 1956 Winter Olympics men’s hockey team. A graduate of Cambridge University, Rigazio played three seasons for the U.S. men’s national ice hockey team and 61 games in the IHL – winning the James Norris Memorial Trophy during the 1958-1959 season.
Prev
Next
Jim Craig
Olympic Team: 1980
Best remembered as goaltender for the 1980 U.S. Olympic hockey team that won the gold medal, Craig stopped 36 of 39 shots on goal to help the U.S. beat the heavily favored Soviet Union. Born in North Easton, Craig would go on to play in the NHL for the Atlanta Flames, Minnesota North Stars, and the Boston Bruins.
Prev
Next
Tom Barrasso
Olympic Team: 2002
Born in Boston, Barrasso was a goaltender for 18 seasons in the NHL and won a silver medal as a member of the U.S. Men’s Hockey team at the 2002 Winter Games. The youngest player ever to win the Vezina Trophy, Borrasso entered the NHL at the age of 18 after graduated from Acton-Boxboro High School. He won two Stanley Cups and was named to the NHL Hall of Fame in 2009.
Prev
Next
Julie Chu
Olympic Teams: 2002, 2006, 2010, 2014
This Harvard University grad is currently playing in her fourth consecutive Winter Olympics Games. Chu has won two silver medals and one bronze. In addition to her prolific Olympic career, this forward won gold at the Women’s World Championships in 2013. One of the greatest college hockey players ever, Chu is the all-time NCAA scoring and assist leader.
Prev
Next
Jack Kirrane
Olympic Teams: 1948, 1960
Born in Brookline, this two-time Olympian helped the U.S. win gold at the 1960 Winter Olympics in Squaw Valley. A member of the U.S. Hockey Hall of Fame, Kirrane went on to serve 38 years with the Brookline Fire Department and 15 years as the rink manager of Harvard University's Bright Hockey Center.
Prev
Next
Chris Drury
Olympic Teams: 2006, 2010
A graduate of Boston University, Drury is a two-time Olympic silver medalist – playing in both the 2006 and 2010 Olympic Games. In addition to a successful International career, this former NHL player one a Stanley Cup with the Colorado Avalanche and is the former captain of the Buffalo Sabres and the New York Rangers. Drury also won the Little League World Series as a youth in Connecticut.
Prev
Next
Meghan Duggan
Olympic Team: 2010
Born in Danvers, Duggan won a silver medal as a member of the U.S. women’s hockey team at the 2010 Winter Olympics in Vancouver. She also won a gold medal representing the U.S. in the 2013 Women’s World Championship. Duggan currently plays for the Boston Blades, a professional women’s hockey team in the Canadian Women’s Hockey League.
Prev
Next
Robbie Ftorek
Olympic Team: 1972
This Needham native and former Boston Bruins head coach won a silver medal as a member of the 1972 U.S. men’s hockey in Sapporo, Japan. Ftorek would go on to play professional hockey for 15 seasons – including stints with the New York Rangers and Detroit Red Wings. After retiring, Ftorek coached six seasons in the NHL.
Prev
Next
Allison Mleczko
Olympic Teams: 1998, 2002
Born in Nantucket, Mleczko held lead the U.S. women’s hockey team to the gold medal at the 1998 Games in Nagano. She would go on to win a silver medal four years later in Salt Lake City. Mleczko played her college hockey at Harvard and helped the Crimson win a national title in 1999. In 1999, she was named the USA Hockey Women’s Player of the Year. Mleczko is a member of the Women’s Beanpot Hall of Fame.
Prev
Next
Gerry Geran
Olympic Team: 1920
Born in Holyoke, Geran won a silver medal with the U.S. Hockey team at the 1920 Olympics in Antwerp. Geran was the first American-born player to make an NHL team. He played a total of 37 NHL games – including 33 with the Boston Bruins.
Prev
Next
Mike Eruzione
Olympic Team: 1980
Born in Withrop, Eruzione is best remembered for scoring the winning goal that propelled the United States over the Soviet Union in the “Miracle on Ice” game in 1980. In addition to winning a gold medal in Lake Placid, Eruzione also played four years for Boston University and went on to be an assistant coach for his Alma mater from 1994-1997.
Related Articles
Enjoy this post? Share it with others.
Email to a friend
Permalink
Follow us on Pinterest Google + Facebook Twitter See It Read It