Angiulo: Defining the Law for Misdemeanor Arrests
Monday, January 11, 2016
In the Commonwealth, there are two categories of crimes: felonies and misdemeanors. A felony is any crime punishable by incarceration in a state prison. Everything else is a misdemeanor. It can sometimes be hard for people to relate to felony level crimes like arson, trafficking in narcotics or assault with a firearm. Many people, whether they will admit to it or not, will be a bit more familiar with the type of crime considered a misdemeanor.
The operation of motor vehicles is a heavily regulated activity and there are a number of behaviors that are misdemeanor crimes. Driving with a suspended license for example carries a risk of fines, jail time, and further license suspension. Operating a vehicle that has a revoked registration is another offense considered a misdemeanor. A simple paperwork slip up or missing an insurance payment or two can lead to either one of these situations. This is why these crimes are relatable in ways that felonies are not.
What the Ubilez court wrestled with is a single question: can an officer arrest a driver for a simple misdemeanor like driving with a revoked registration. In classic legal fashion the answer is “it depends.”
When it comes to misdemeanors involving motor vehicles there are some crimes that can definitely end in arrest. Section 21 of Chapter 90 of the Massachusetts General Laws lists these arrestable offenses. Among them are Operation Under the Influence of Drugs or Alcohol and Homicide by Motor Vehicle. The problem was, there are more motor vehicle misdemeanors out there than are listed in that statute. Operating with a revoked registration is just one of them.
In the absence of explicit statutory authority, the Appeals Court needed to step in and make law by relying on precedent. Citing cases from 1934 and 1974 the court found that arrest is appropriate for a misdemeanor like operating with a revoked registration only in certain circumstances. The circumstances required include a breach of the peace that is committed in front of an officer. Also, the offense and arrest must basically happen at the same time. Unless all three elements are present an arrest will not be considered justified.
For those that still don't see the importance of this decision ask yourself this question: are all your parking tickets paid? If not, it may be more difficult to reinstate your driver's license the next time it's due.
- Angiulo: Federal 1st Circuit Court of Appeals Says Growing Weed Still a Crime
- Angiulo: Employee Injuries and Employer Liability
- Angiulo: Promises Made in Auto Insurance Applications May Stick
- Angiulo: Massachusetts Motor Vehicle Stops and the Odor of Marijuana Continued
- Angiulo: Cell Phone Tracking in Massachusetts
- Angiulo: Sometimes a Spouse Really Does Get Half Your Stuff in a Divorce
- Angiulo: Overtime Pay for Employees and Employer Obligations
- Angiulo: An Insurance Agent at the Intersection of Business Model and Criminal Act
- Angiulo: Drunk Driving Charges and Commercial Driver’s License Suspensions
- Angiulo: Freedom of Speech and Political Campaigns
- Angiulo: Challenging the Legality of Motor Vehicle Stops by Police
- Angiulo: When Working From Home Causes a Lawsuit
- Angiulo: Railroad in Grafton Subject to Federal Law
- Angiulo: Drug Dependent Defendants Have Options
- Angiulo: Defamation, Opinions, and Rock n Roll
- Angiulo: American Civilians Injured Abroad Have Limited Options
- Angiulo: Arbitration Requirements, Consumer Protection & the Supreme Court
- Angiulo: Taking Immigrants Into Custody
- Angiulo: House Judiciary Committe Reports Out Sentencing Reform Act of 2015
- Angiulo: Law Enforcement, Qualified Immunity and Use of Force
- Cheat Sheet 11, The Patriarca Papers Unveil Sam Giancana, Meyer Lansky and Jerry Angiulo
- Angiulo: Custody of Refugees Without Parents
- Angiulo: Further Refining Parental Discipline Standards in MA
- Angiulo: Involuntary Commitment for Drug & Alcohol Abuse in MA
- Angiulo: What Happens When a Witness has a Sealed Record?